Top 9 Best Pizza Restaurants in Carmel Indiana (2024 Updated)

Carmel, Indiana is a unique city north of Indianapolis known for its quality of life, excellent schools, parks, and diverse dining options. But one thing Carmel is especially revered for is its delicious pizza joints scattered throughout the city. From Chicago-style deep dish to artisanal wood-fired pies, Carmel offers an array of pizza restaurants sure to satisfy any palette.

If you’re searching for the best pizza in Carmel Indiana, look no further than this list of the top 9 must-try pizzerias that will have you craving a slice.

Rosati’s Pizza

Address: 890 E. 116th St., Carmel, IN 46032

Phone: 317-983-3638

A Carmel staple for over 20 years, Rosati’s Pizza proudly serves some of the best pizza in Carmel Indiana. This family-owned shop uses an authentic recipe passed down through generations to craft mouth-watering pies with flavorful homemade sauce and freshly grated mozzarella.

With an extensive variety of pizza options and toppings like their signature thin crust, deep dish, and Chicago-style, you’re sure to find a pie suited to your tastes. Toppings range from classic pepperoni and Italian sausage to inventive options like blackened chicken.

While Rosati’s is acclaimed for pizza, their menu also includes pastas, salads, sandwiches, and more to satisfy any appetite. Whether you opt for dine-in, carry-out, or delivery, you can expect fresh, quality ingredients and friendly service.

Lou Malnati’s Carmel

Address: 11435 Spring Mill Rd. Suite 170, Carmel, IN 46032

Phone: +1 317 975 1980

For authentic Chicago-style deep dish pizza in Carmel, Lou Malnati’s is a must-visit. Part of a family-owned chain started in Chicago, Lou’s has perfected the buttery, flaky crust filled with chunky tomatoes and mounds of mozzarella that defines this regional style.

Lou Malnati’s dedication to excellence shines through in every detail, from the fresh, handmade ingredients to the renowned sauce recipe. Dine-in and take-out options are available to enjoy their famous pies right from the source.

Beyond deep dish, Lou’s offers mouth-watering thin crust pizzas, pastas, salads, and desserts like their signature chocolate chip cake.

Blaze Pizza

Address: 12697 N. Pennsylvania St., Carmel, IN 46032

Phone: +1 317 343 9193

For customized personal pizzas created with lightning speed, visit Blaze Pizza. This nationwide chain delivers a Chipotle-style pizza experience – choose your crust, sauce, cheese, and unlimited toppings to craft your ideal pie.

With options like olive oil crusts, vegan cheese, gluten-free dough, and 40+ fresh veggie, meat, and sauce toppings, you can create any pizza you crave. Watch as friendly staff toss, top, and cook your pizza in just minutes in their open kitchen.

Blaze also offers salads, desserts, and drinks like lemonades and agua frescas. Their convenient location by the Carmel City Center makes this a perfect on-the-go dining option.

Crafter’s Draft House

Address: 2430 E. 146th St., Carmel, IN 46033

Phone: +1 317 798 2056

For a gourmet pizza experience, look no further than Crafter’s Draft House. This local favorite exudes the essence of an artisanal pizzeria through its carefully crafted menu and charming atmosphere.

Signature pies like The Forager with wild mushrooms, fontina, and truffle oil exemplify their knack for combining unique, high-quality ingredients. Pair your pizza with one of 30 craft beers on tap for the ultimate food and drink pairing.

Beyond pizza, Crafter’s offers fresh salads, burgers, and shareable apps highlighting local and seasonal produce. Their outstanding service and established reputation make this a beloved community pizza joint in Carmel.

Mellow Mushroom

Address: 2340 E. 116th St., Carmel, IN 46032

Phone: +1 317 846 2400

Mellow Mushroom brings a funky, eclectic vibe perfect for hanging out with friends and devouring some creatively topped pies. This nationwide chain is known for its freshly made pizza dough and unique ingredient combinations.

The fun, psychedelic-themed interior matches their innovative menu. Pies like the Funky Q. Chicken with fried chicken, caramelized onions, and BBQ sauce exemplify their anything-goes approach.

Beyond pizza, the menu offers salads, hoagies, calzones, and munchies like pretzel bites with beer cheese dipping sauce. Quench your thirst with local brews, cocktails, or organic sodas.

Pies & Pints

Address: 14550 Clay Terrace Blvd, Suite 100 Carmel, IN 46032

Phone: +1 317 688 7477

For the best of both worlds, visit Pies & Pints – a family-owned brewery, Neapolitan pizzeria, and pub under one roof. Their dedication to handcrafted food and drink shines through in every bite and sip.

Pies & Pints offers inventive pizza options like The Royale with fig jam, prosciutto, and gorgonzola. Pair your pie with one of 24 rotating craft brews or a cocktail like their Bloody Mary with bacon.

Beyond pizza, the menu includes fresh salads, paninis, and shareable appetizers. Weekly specials like Taco Tuesdays add to the fun. The lively atmosphere and welcoming staff make this a go-to Carmel hangout.

Bazbeaux Pizza

Address: 111 W. Main St., Carmel, IN 46032

Phone: +1 317 848 4488

For an upscale pizza experience in Carmel, Bazbeaux offers gourmet pies in a rustic-chic environment. Unique pies like The Napolitano with Italian sausage and pepperoni exemplify their specialty offerings.

Foodies will love creations like The Luke with prosciutto, blue cheese, fig preserves, and arugula. Tchoupitoulas combines crawfish tails, andouille sausage, red onions, and ale cream sauce for a taste of New Orleans.

Beyond pizza, Bazbeaux serves creative salads, calzones, hoagies, and shareable plates. Their full bar offers a wide beer selection, wines, and signature cocktails to complement your meal.

Pizzology

Address: 13190 Hazel Dell Pkwy, Ste 180 Carmel, IN 46033

Phone: +1 317 844 2550

For a quintessential neighborhood pizza joint, look no further than Pizzology. This Carmel favorite specializes in artisanal wood-fired pizzas baked to perfection in their stone oven.

Creative options like The Rocket with salami, hot coppa, basil, and tomato sauce exemplify their gourmet pies. Those with adventurous tastes will love monthly specialty offerings like Thai curry chicken pizza.

Beyond pizza, Pizzology’s diverse menu includes starters, pastas, salads, and desserts. Dine-in to enjoy the welcoming, casual ambiance or order take-out or delivery for a quality meal.

Greek’s Pizzeria

Address: 120 E Main St, Carmel, IN 46032

Phone: +1 317 848 1969

For a classic pizza parlor experience, look no further than Greek’s Pizzeria. Family-owned since 1989, Greek’s offers excellent pizza and freshly baked breadsticks with fast and friendly service.

Sink your teeth into their famous hand-tossed pizzas with zesty sauce and gooey cheese baked to perfection. Traditional toppings like pepperoni and Italian sausage satisfy, while specialty options like Greek’s Special delight.

Dine-in or carry-out, you can expect quality ingredients, reasonable prices, and good old-fashioned service from the hard-working staff at Greek’s. It’s no wonder this local favorite has been a Carmel institution for over 30 years.

This list shows Carmel offers much more than just chains when it comes to pizza. With revered Chicago-style deep dish, fast-casual custom pies, and artisanal wood-fired creations, Carmel has a pizza style to suit any preference.

Whether you seek family-friendly affordability or upscale dining, you’ll find quality ingredients, creative twists, and craft beer or cocktails to accompany the perfect slice. From old-school parlors to funky vibes to Neapolitan mastery, Carmel does pizza right.

So next time you get a pizza craving in this Indianapolis suburb, turn to the local pizza gems scattered throughout the city. Grab take-out after the Carmel Farmers Market, refuel kids after soccer practice, or enjoy an upscale date night out over great pizza and drinks. With so many distinctive options for the best pizza in Carmel Indiana, your next favorite slice is waiting to be devoured.